Dear Garrett L. White,
As we both are aware, I have on a number of occasions approached a member of the fairer sex and have attempted to put to words the thoughts which were present in my mind. I’ve always been successful in the sense that a statement approximating my thoughts was always made, but I can rarely say that I’ve been entirely content with the content of my speech. And I’ve certainly not always been content with the outcome, but that’s a topic for another time.
It often feels that the thoughts and opinions swirling in one’s mind are so very clear, but when it comes to writing them down or expressing them to an interlocutor, this is where the trouble can begin. It may well be that there isn’t a better way to express these thoughts, or maybe it is the process of discussion that allows the rough block to be chiseled down into something beautiful. Or maybe the ideas that one has in the mind are mostly vibes based and not nearly as thought out as hoped. I am a huge lover of reformed theology and monarchy, and on many an occasion I’ve had the honor and privilege of defending these positions. I would like to say that I have done well to uphold the rigor and value of these positions, but that isn’t really true. Many times I have just felt stuck and I knew that I was convinced by these ideas, but I couldn’t really explain why. This feelings based approach is fine when it comes to ice cream flavors or one’s favorite color, but not for anything of substance.
I wonder if the slow death of literacy and the increasingly video and short form content focused society is leading to more of this. Maybe in the past it was easy to express oneself in books and writing, but now many people feel inclined to identify their feelings and opinions with short edits and videos that are mostly music and vibes, not any factual information. As a pretentious educated lover of reading who enjoys listening to jazz while drinking gin and discussing poetry, I am in no way immune from the pull of short form content and the dreaded edit. I wonder if it isn’t becoming more common to share videos with others and just hope that they feel similarly after watching them? Then one can use that as the basis of convincing others of an opinion. It certainly feels like advertisements are getting dumber and more vibes based as time goes on.
At any rate, discussions are great and a wonderful way to mold others and to be molded yourself. It doesn’t take a triumphant debate win to change opinions, the act of testing out your own thoughts on others is already doing a lot. Plus, when two or more people come together honestly and just discuss how they are feeling, it is hard not to have good and impactful conversations. I wonder if the whole ‘debate me bro’ and ‘owning the libs’ trends from the 2010s weren’t more harmful than they were good. For a time, everybody just wanted to make their talking point and go home. Whereas it is easy to find common ground with a huge swath of people, as long as everybody involved is earnest.
The more we dig into this, the even sillier it seems. When in life is it even healthy to win conversations? With a spouse? That sounds like a recipe for trouble. I also don’t think it helps to make friends if everything is about winning. Though, to be fair, even if somebody is being earnest it is still hard to talk to people who are flat out wrong. There are a great many topics where a plethora of opinions are valid and interesting, but this isn’t always the case. It may be sweet hearing a toddler talk about how their favorite dinosaur is going to take over the world, but it isn’t a conversation of equals. Likewise, I am open and willing to discuss most anything, but a flat earther is a bridge too fair. I can’t honestly contend with somebody who holds such a nonsense view, and there are still more views like this. But for most normal people, coming together and discussing meaningful topics honestly is an edifying experience. And honestly, is there really anything better for the heart and soul?
Now, at this point I’ve avoided Plato for long enough, it is time. Your question: When a baby is born, how do you know if it is deformed? Your answer; or rather the Platonic view is that you know the concept of a baby’s proper form. You know what a baby is supposed to look like. Sure, this might explain how we would know if a baby is deformed, but that doesn’t explain how this concept came to us in the first place. I would argue that many of our ideas and idealizations of things come from society. We know what a baby is supposed to look like because we have seen babies before and there are others who have been able to compare and contrast healthy and deformed babies. You might say that there is an ideal baby, but I would ask; who defines this standard and how are we supposed to know it exists? Babies come in many different colors and shapes and forms and sizes. There are certainly deformities and ways of knowing when a baby isn’t healthy. But I would argue it is easier to know if a baby is deformed than if it is ideal. You might say that this is the point, and that the ideal baby isn’t possible on this mortal plane. But if this concept is unapproachable and only theoretical, then what’s the point?
If I was being charitable, you could maybe get me to believe that in the realm of forms there is an ideal form of a tree, a chair, a baby, or a dog. But what about modern day items? Is there an ideal form of the car, smart phone, hair dryer, or microphone? What about the ideal form of the tree? Do all trees share the same ideal, is there one perfect idea of the tree? Or does each type of tree, pine, oak, aspen, etc, have its own ideal form? I would hate to expand this to different races of cats, dogs, or heaven forbid people, but this is a question that Platonists have to answer.
Plus, where is the proof of the realm of forms? Philosophically it might make enough sense, but I don’t think this can be proven in any meaningful sense. Not only that, but it isn’t even Biblical. Last I checked the Bible doesn’t say anything about this. This realm of forms could mesh with the Bible, but it might as well be nonsense all the same. To be fair, there is some truth in this idea. When it comes to more abstract concepts or traits, there are ideals. There is an ideal love, truth, beauty, goodness, patience, mercy, justice, etc. But rather than being present in some ethereal pagan dimension, these are all traits that are most fully realized in the divine. The triune good is the truest form of truth, beauty, and goodness. The goodness we see on earth isn’t quite a cheap imitation of true goodness, I don’t think that would be fair. But goodness is only fully realized in God.
I am not as philosophically well read as you, nor do I have nearly as much knowledge about the Greek classics. However, as a layman, as someone who hasn’t been swayed by the charm of Plato, I find it hard to take him seriously. I am sure that there is a truth and beauty to his work, but in my current limited understanding of Plato, I find his ideas to be silly, funny even. The idea that the concept or the idea of something being more real than the thing itself, is not something I’m convinced of at all. To someone deep in the philosophical world, I am sure the realm of forms seems brilliant. To those of us back in the real world, it’s kinda goofy. In the spirit of 2010s online trends, change my mind.
You say that without the realm of forms or something similar, it is hard to say whether one thing is supposed to be one way or another. Says who? Does empirical evidence not suffice? If we have taken notes of how hundreds of chickens look like, it is pretty easy to get a baseline and to know what is a proper chicken and what isn’t one. In this case, as in most others, the answer lies on a spectrum. It is not usually binary whether a chicken is ideal or not. Some chickens are certainly deformed, but others are maybe just smaller. Some are maybe even healthier and more fit than average, but still not normal. Is this then the ideal? You assume that someone or something outside of humanity has to define what something should be like or not. Which in a way I would agree with. God is the author and definer of everything in creation. He knows what the ideal forms of everything are, but this by no means has to involve the realm of forms. Nor does God’s authorship draw strong lines between the real and the ideal. Jesus Christ is fully God and fully man. We are fallen creatures whose entire being, flesh and spirit needs to be transformed and redeemed by His grace. I fear that if we make the separation between flesh and spirit too strong, that we risk becoming gnostic and not appreciating that God will perfect the flesh as well as the spirit.
To close, let me ask something else entirely (as if there’s not already more than enough to respond to). Is there not some value in participating in participation? God is sovereign enough that His will can’t help but be done. The lilies of the field are beautiful because God is beauty and because His whim wills it so. As people made in the image of God, we uniquely have to contend not only with God’s sovereign will, but with our own responsibility and accountability for choosing sin. Because of this, it is all the more special and indeed beautiful when we choose to participate actively. Participation may not always be active, but it sure is better when it’s voluntary, right?
Veritas vos liberabit.
Your friend,
Nate Martin
P.S. I couldn’t quite manage to steer the ship clear of Platonism. In fact, I crashed us right into it. I hope this was a decision I won’t regret. Time will tell.

Leave a Reply